Tesla Faces A $56 Billion Query. Does Elon Musk Have The Votes?

Make no mistake: Whether or not CEO Elon Musk ultimately will get his extremely contested $56 billion payday or not, this week will decide the long run trajectory of Tesla. As a result of if a much-ballyhooed shareholder election would not go the best way Musk desires, this firm may look very totally different at its subsequent annual assembly. 

This Monday version of our Essential Supplies morning information roundup units the stage for one of many greatest moments in company governance we’re more likely to see this decade. Additionally on faucet as we speak: why investments in large battery factories appear to be slowing down, and some extra particulars trickle out on Fisker’s inside strife. 

30%: Does Musk Have The Votes?

This Thursday afternoon is Tesla’s Annual Shareholder Assembly for 2024, and as we have written earlier than, just a few essential objects have been put to an investor vote over the previous few months. Specifically, they embody reincorporating in Texas as a substitute of Delaware; reelecting two administrators, together with Musk’s brother Kimbal Musk; and maybe most crucially, whether or not or to not reaffirm a large pay package deal for Musk {that a} Delaware Chancery Courtroom decide spiked after an investor’s lawsuit earlier this yr. 

As a number of authorized specialists have famous, this vote is not going to magically give Musk the $56 billion pay package deal he was initially granted in 2018. However the shareholders declaring such assist for him may transfer issues in that course with an attraction or a brand new listening to.

If it would not occur, Musk and his board chair have repeatedly intimated he’ll pursue AI and robotics initiatives—which have captured most of his consideration as of late—”exterior of Tesla,” which means it may see his departure from the corporate. This week’s vote, then, is a referendum on Musk’s management and whether or not or not the corporate’s future will see him on the helm. 

Given how a lot Musk has elevated Tesla’s inventory value through the years, it looks as if a no brainer for traders to vote sure. However as Reuters notes as we speak, huge, institutional funding corporations have been skeptical of Musk’s management at Tesla (or perceived lack thereof) as its gross sales and future product plans appear to slide, all whereas the CEO appears distracted by his possession of X and being lively within the tradition wars. (He spent lots of Friday morning posting memes about Dr. Anthony Fauci, for instance.)

So with the large shareholders seemingly blended, Tesla has launched an aggressive promoting marketing campaign geared toward smaller, retail shareholders as a substitute—it is probably the most promoting the corporate has ever performed, actually. 

However retail traders infamously barely prove for these elections, even when your common $TSLA shareholder is ostensibly extra engaged than most. So does Musk have the votes or not? The depth of this push mere days earlier than the assembly has some observers questioning that he might not. From Reuters: 

In a put up on his social media platform X on Saturday Musk wrote: “Up to now, roughly 90% of retail shareholders who’ve voted have voted in favor of each resolutions,” apparently together with the one on his pay.

Bruce Goldfarb, president of Okapi Companions, a proxy solicitor not concerned on this vote, mentioned 90% assist from retail traders could be “about regular” because the class usually favors administration. However such traders often do not vote, posing a problem for Tesla.

“Retail shareholders are wildly apathetic even when they’re supportive,” Goldfarb mentioned. Mother-and-pop traders solely voted about 30% of their shares in 2023, in accordance with vote-processing firm Broadridge, in comparison with 80% for institutional traders.

Principally, this might find yourself lots nearer than Musk ever imagined it might. And even when blue-check, paying X subscribers are all-in on Musk’s management, X isn’t actual life; they might find yourself a vocal minority right here. Or Musk will sail ahead after which should ship on his huge AI push at Tesla. Legitimately, I don’t know how issues will go for him this week.

Count on extra on this because it occurs at InsideEVs.

60%: Gigafactory Slowdown

In the meantime, this yr has confirmed to be an especially bizarre one on the EV development entrance. Increasingly more, what we’re seeing within the U.S. particularly is that non-Tesla EV gross sales are rising, however the greatest electrical automaker’s gross sales are down, dragging the market down in combination with it. It is in all probability truthful to say EV gross sales are fairly a bit slower in Europe, nevertheless.

Therefore, automakers are rethinking their plans to go all-electric. That has profoundly harmful implications for our local weather, however automotive firms are within the revenue enterprise, not the environmental one. 

At this time, The Info experiences that as a part of this gross sales development slowdown, a number of automakers and out of doors corporations are hitting pause on deliberate battery “gigafactories” in Europe and North America: 

Mercedes-Benz and Stellantis final week froze building of two European battery gigafactories they have been constructing by way of a three way partnership. The businesses need to take a recent take a look at the vegetation in hopes of lowering the worth of their electrical autos, pushed largely by the price of the batteries, the costliest element in an EV. If they’ll scale back the price of their batteries, maybe they’ll promote extra EVs and higher compete with Chinese language rivals.

[…] Within the battery and EV investor mania of 2020 and 2021, present and would-be battery producers appear to have significantly overestimated shopper demand for EVs, a minimum of by way of 2030. There is no such thing as a approach of figuring out how a lot extra capability there may be in Western plans, however we have now categorized 37 of the gigafactories in our database—greater than half—as both unsure or unlikely to be accomplished.

Emphasis theirs, in addition to mine. However as The Info experiences, these firms might have put their eggs within the flawed battery-chemistry basket:

It’s because lots of the battery makers and their auto firm companions appear to have chosen the flawed kind of battery to fabricate: Most plan to make nickel-manganese-cobalt batteries, which have excessive vitality density and ship the best potential driving vary however are comparatively costly and topic to extra potential provide bottlenecks—for nickel, lithium and cobalt. Chinese language firms in distinction have positioned their bets largely on sometimes cheaper lithium-iron-phosphate batteries, which face a single potential bottleneck—for lithium. At this time, most Teslas and Chinese language EVs use LFP, which is a significant motive why their vehicles are cheaper than Western fashions.

Slowing down on battery plant development and hoping that tariffs alone will head off an more and more highly effective Chinese language auto business looks as if a questionable transfer within the long-term. 

90%: Extra Staff Sound Off About Fisker’s Destiny

Fisker Pear production-intent EV

That automotive you see above is the Fisker Pear, an EV that was meant to value about $30,000 earlier than any incentives. It is truthful to say it is unlikely to see the sunshine of day now, as Fisker’s future appears extra doubtful than ever. The corporate has been roiled by layoffs, customer support points, a halt to the manufacturing of its Ocean SUV and extra challenges. 

A brand new report from veteran journalist Nicole Wakelin in CarBuzz options claims from extra ex-employees, and so they observe with what we have been reporting as effectively. One element I had not seen earlier than: in April, a Fisker government warned the remaining staff they may all be laid off round June 28 if the corporate would not safe additional cash or a brand new purchaser. 

It is powerful to say if that is nonetheless the case; this letter is now virtually two months outdated and it was reportedly offered by an worker who was reduce in Might. However June 28 is quickly developing and there is not any information but of Fisker getting any type of lifeline. 

100%: If Musk Leaves, Who Ought to Lead Tesla?

If Musk is basically poised to maneuver on from Tesla if he would not get what he desires—an end result I nonetheless suppose is much from sure—the fallout could be immense. It could possible tank the worth of the corporate’s inventory value, a lot of which hinges on Musk and his crew ultimately “fixing” the query of totally autonomous driving.

But when he does transfer on, it’d hardly be the tip of Tesla. Who do you suppose ought to take the reins if a post-Musk future is basically within the playing cards?

Contact the writer: [email protected]